Skip to content

Butter Side Down & Atomic Lizard

  • Home
  • Catalog
  • Contact
  • About Us
  • Rubber Stamps
    • Rubber Stamp Information
    • All Rubber Stamps
    • Ancient World
      • Ancient World Rubber Stamps
      • Egyptian Rubber Stamps
      • Megaliths & Geoglyphs Rubber Stamps
    • Insects & Butterfly Rubber Stamps
      • Butterflies & Moths
      • Insects and Creepy Crawlies
    • Fantasy & Labyrinth Rubber Stamps
    • Fish and Marine Life Rubber Stamps
    • Fossil & Mineral Rubber Stamps
      • Fossil Rubber Stamps
      • Shark Tooth Rubber Stamps
      • Trilobite Rubber Stamps
      • Mineral Treasure Rubber Stamps
    • History Rubber Stamps
      • Medieval Rubber Stamps
      • Japan and Asia Rubber Stamps
      • Historical Rubber Stamps
    • Bigfoot, Monsters & Halloween
      • Halloween Rubber Stamps
      • Bigfoot & Cryptids
      • Monster Rubber Stamps
    • Odds and Ends
      • Animal Rubber Stamps
      • Odds & Ends Rubber Stamps
    • Teddy Bear Rubber Stamps
    • Mystical & Magical Rubber Stamps
  • Atomic Lizard Earrings
  • Ornaments
  • Coffee Mugs
  • Cryptid Collection
  • Sale items!
Log in

Country/region

  • USD $ | Australia
  • USD $ | Austria
  • USD $ | Belgium
  • USD $ | Canada
  • USD $ | Cook Islands
  • USD $ | Czechia
  • USD $ | Denmark
  • USD $ | Fiji
  • USD $ | Finland
  • USD $ | France
  • USD $ | French Polynesia
  • USD $ | Germany
  • USD $ | Hong Kong SAR
  • USD $ | Ireland
  • USD $ | Israel
  • USD $ | Italy
  • USD $ | Japan
  • USD $ | Kiribati
  • USD $ | Kuwait
  • USD $ | Malaysia
  • USD $ | Mexico
  • USD $ | Nauru
  • USD $ | Netherlands
  • USD $ | New Caledonia
  • USD $ | New Zealand
  • USD $ | Norfolk Island
  • USD $ | Norway
  • USD $ | Papua New Guinea
  • USD $ | Philippines
  • USD $ | Pitcairn Islands
  • USD $ | Poland
  • USD $ | Portugal
  • USD $ | Samoa
  • USD $ | Singapore
  • USD $ | Solomon Islands
  • USD $ | South Korea
  • USD $ | Spain
  • USD $ | Sweden
  • USD $ | Switzerland
  • USD $ | Taiwan
  • USD $ | Thailand
  • USD $ | Timor-Leste
  • USD $ | Tokelau
  • USD $ | Ukraine
  • USD $ | United Arab Emirates
  • USD $ | United Kingdom
  • USD $ | United States
  • USD $ | Vanuatu
  • USD $ | Vatican City
  • USD $ | Vietnam
    Butter Side Down Stamps and Atomic Lizard Logo
    • Home
    • Catalog
    • Contact
    • About Us
    • Rubber Stamps
      • Rubber Stamp Information
      • All Rubber Stamps
      • Ancient World
        • Ancient World Rubber Stamps
        • Egyptian Rubber Stamps
        • Megaliths & Geoglyphs Rubber Stamps
      • Insects & Butterfly Rubber Stamps
        • Butterflies & Moths
        • Insects and Creepy Crawlies
      • Fantasy & Labyrinth Rubber Stamps
      • Fish and Marine Life Rubber Stamps
      • Fossil & Mineral Rubber Stamps
        • Fossil Rubber Stamps
        • Shark Tooth Rubber Stamps
        • Trilobite Rubber Stamps
        • Mineral Treasure Rubber Stamps
      • History Rubber Stamps
        • Medieval Rubber Stamps
        • Japan and Asia Rubber Stamps
        • Historical Rubber Stamps
      • Bigfoot, Monsters & Halloween
        • Halloween Rubber Stamps
        • Bigfoot & Cryptids
        • Monster Rubber Stamps
      • Odds and Ends
        • Animal Rubber Stamps
        • Odds & Ends Rubber Stamps
      • Teddy Bear Rubber Stamps
      • Mystical & Magical Rubber Stamps
    • Atomic Lizard Earrings
    • Ornaments
    • Coffee Mugs
    • Cryptid Collection
    • Sale items!

    Country/region

    • USD $ | Australia
    • USD $ | Austria
    • USD $ | Belgium
    • USD $ | Canada
    • USD $ | Cook Islands
    • USD $ | Czechia
    • USD $ | Denmark
    • USD $ | Fiji
    • USD $ | Finland
    • USD $ | France
    • USD $ | French Polynesia
    • USD $ | Germany
    • USD $ | Hong Kong SAR
    • USD $ | Ireland
    • USD $ | Israel
    • USD $ | Italy
    • USD $ | Japan
    • USD $ | Kiribati
    • USD $ | Kuwait
    • USD $ | Malaysia
    • USD $ | Mexico
    • USD $ | Nauru
    • USD $ | Netherlands
    • USD $ | New Caledonia
    • USD $ | New Zealand
    • USD $ | Norfolk Island
    • USD $ | Norway
    • USD $ | Papua New Guinea
    • USD $ | Philippines
    • USD $ | Pitcairn Islands
    • USD $ | Poland
    • USD $ | Portugal
    • USD $ | Samoa
    • USD $ | Singapore
    • USD $ | Solomon Islands
    • USD $ | South Korea
    • USD $ | Spain
    • USD $ | Sweden
    • USD $ | Switzerland
    • USD $ | Taiwan
    • USD $ | Thailand
    • USD $ | Timor-Leste
    • USD $ | Tokelau
    • USD $ | Ukraine
    • USD $ | United Arab Emirates
    • USD $ | United Kingdom
    • USD $ | United States
    • USD $ | Vanuatu
    • USD $ | Vatican City
    • USD $ | Vietnam
    Log in Cart

    Item added to your cart

    View cart

    Filter:

    Availability
    0 selected Reset
    Availability
    Price
    The highest price is $17.95 Reset
    $
    $
    Remove all

    46 products

    Filter and sort Filter

    Filter and sort

    Filter

    46 products

    Availability
    Clear
    Price

    The highest price is $17.95

    $
    $
    Clear
    Remove all
    Remove all

    46 products

    • FeeGee Mermaid Rubber Stamp

      FeeGee Mermaid Rubber Stamp

      Sale

      FeeGee Mermaid Rubber Stamp

      Regular price From $2.50 USD
      Regular price $5.00 USD Sale price From $2.50 USD
      Unit price /  per 
      Sale
    • Flying Mothman

      Flying Mothman Cryptid Monster Rubber Stamp

      Sale

      Flying Mothman Cryptid Monster Rubber Stamp

      Regular price From $3.50 USD
      Regular price $5.00 USD Sale price From $3.50 USD
      Unit price /  per 
      Sale
    • Giant Octopus Rubber Stamp

      Giant Octopus Rubber Stamp

      Giant Octopus Rubber Stamp

      Regular price From $5.50 USD
      Regular price $5.00 USD Sale price From $5.50 USD
      Unit price /  per 
    • Gray Alien Rubber Stamp

      Gray Alien Rubber Stamp

      Gray Alien Rubber Stamp

      Regular price From $5.00 USD
      Regular price $5.00 USD Sale price From $5.00 USD
      Unit price /  per 
    • Wyoming Jackalope cryptid

      Jackalope Jackrabbit Rubber Stamp

      Jackalope Jackrabbit Rubber Stamp

      Regular price From $5.00 USD
      Regular price $5.00 USD Sale price From $5.00 USD
      Unit price /  per 
    • Jersey Devil ceramic ornament

      Jersey Devil Ceramic Ornament

      Jersey Devil Ceramic Ornament

      Regular price $11.95 USD
      Regular price $11.95 USD Sale price $11.95 USD
      Unit price /  per 
    • 13th child of old Mother Leeds

      Jersey Devil Rubber Stamp 13th Child

      Jersey Devil Rubber Stamp 13th Child

      Regular price From $5.50 USD
      Regular price $5.50 USD Sale price From $5.50 USD
      Unit price /  per 
    • Jersey Devil Earrings

      Jersey Devil Spider Web Agate Dangle Earrings

      Jersey Devil Spider Web Agate Dangle Earrings

      Regular price $9.95 USD
      Regular price $9.95 USD Sale price $9.95 USD
      Unit price /  per 
    • Rampaging gigantic squid.

      Killer Squid Rubber Stamp

      Killer Squid Rubber Stamp

      Regular price From $6.50 USD
      Regular price $5.50 USD Sale price From $6.50 USD
      Unit price /  per 
    • Leviathan itself rises from the ocean depths.

      Leviathan Sea Monster Rubber Stamp

      Sale

      Leviathan Sea Monster Rubber Stamp

      Regular price From $3.50 USD
      Regular price $5.00 USD Sale price From $3.50 USD
      Unit price /  per 
      Sale
    • Loch Ness Monster by Urquhart Castle

      Loch Ness Monster Rubber Stamp

      Loch Ness Monster Rubber Stamp

      Regular price From $5.00 USD
      Regular price $5.00 USD Sale price From $5.00 USD
      Unit price /  per 
    • Misunderstood Sasquatch Hunters Coffee Mug

      Misunderstood Sasquatch Hunters Coffee Mug

      Misunderstood Sasquatch Hunters Coffee Mug

      Regular price $17.95 USD
      Regular price $14.95 USD Sale price $17.95 USD
      Unit price /  per 
    • Mothman Ceramic Ornament

      Mothman Ceramic Ornament

      Mothman Ceramic Ornament

      Regular price $11.95 USD
      Regular price $11.95 USD Sale price $11.95 USD
      Unit price /  per 
    • Mothman Moon Rubber Stamp

      Mothman Moon Rubber Stamp

      Mothman Moon Rubber Stamp

      Regular price From $5.00 USD
      Regular price $5.00 USD Sale price From $5.00 USD
      Unit price /  per 
    • New Jersey Cryptid Hunters Coffee Mug

      New Jersey Cryptid Hunters Coffee Mug

      New Jersey Cryptid Hunters Coffee Mug

      Regular price $17.95 USD
      Regular price $14.95 USD Sale price $17.95 USD
      Unit price /  per 
    • New Jersey Cryptid Hunters Rubber Stamp

      New Jersey Cryptid Hunters Rubber Stamp

      New Jersey Cryptid Hunters Rubber Stamp

      Regular price From $5.00 USD
      Regular price $5.00 USD Sale price From $5.00 USD
      Unit price /  per 
    • 1
    • 2
    • 3

    Subscribe for information on new products and special deals!

    Country/region

    • USD $ | Australia
    • USD $ | Austria
    • USD $ | Belgium
    • USD $ | Canada
    • USD $ | Cook Islands
    • USD $ | Czechia
    • USD $ | Denmark
    • USD $ | Fiji
    • USD $ | Finland
    • USD $ | France
    • USD $ | French Polynesia
    • USD $ | Germany
    • USD $ | Hong Kong SAR
    • USD $ | Ireland
    • USD $ | Israel
    • USD $ | Italy
    • USD $ | Japan
    • USD $ | Kiribati
    • USD $ | Kuwait
    • USD $ | Malaysia
    • USD $ | Mexico
    • USD $ | Nauru
    • USD $ | Netherlands
    • USD $ | New Caledonia
    • USD $ | New Zealand
    • USD $ | Norfolk Island
    • USD $ | Norway
    • USD $ | Papua New Guinea
    • USD $ | Philippines
    • USD $ | Pitcairn Islands
    • USD $ | Poland
    • USD $ | Portugal
    • USD $ | Samoa
    • USD $ | Singapore
    • USD $ | Solomon Islands
    • USD $ | South Korea
    • USD $ | Spain
    • USD $ | Sweden
    • USD $ | Switzerland
    • USD $ | Taiwan
    • USD $ | Thailand
    • USD $ | Timor-Leste
    • USD $ | Tokelau
    • USD $ | Ukraine
    • USD $ | United Arab Emirates
    • USD $ | United Kingdom
    • USD $ | United States
    • USD $ | Vanuatu
    • USD $ | Vatican City
    • USD $ | Vietnam
    Payment methods
    • American Express
    • Apple Pay
    • Diners Club
    • Discover
    • Google Pay
    • Mastercard
    • PayPal
    • Shop Pay
    • Venmo
    • Visa
    © 2025, Butter Side Down Powered by Shopify
    • Refund policy
    • Privacy policy
    • Terms of service
    • Shipping policy
    • Contact information
    • Choosing a selection results in a full page refresh.
    • Opens in a new window.