Skip to content

Butter Side Down & Atomic Lizard

  • Home
  • Catalog
  • Contact
  • About Us
  • Rubber Stamps
    • Rubber Stamp Information
    • All Rubber Stamps
    • Ancient World
      • Ancient World Rubber Stamps
      • Egyptian Rubber Stamps
      • Megaliths & Geoglyphs Rubber Stamps
    • Insects & Butterfly Rubber Stamps
      • Butterflies & Moths
      • Insects and Creepy Crawlies
    • Fantasy & Labyrinth Rubber Stamps
    • Fish and Marine Life Rubber Stamps
    • Fossil & Mineral Rubber Stamps
      • Fossil Rubber Stamps
      • Shark Tooth Rubber Stamps
      • Trilobite Rubber Stamps
      • Mineral Treasure Rubber Stamps
    • History Rubber Stamps
      • Medieval Rubber Stamps
      • Japan and Asia Rubber Stamps
      • Historical Rubber Stamps
    • Bigfoot, Monsters & Halloween
      • Halloween Rubber Stamps
      • Bigfoot & Cryptids
      • Monster Rubber Stamps
    • Odds and Ends
      • Animal Rubber Stamps
      • Odds & Ends Rubber Stamps
    • Teddy Bear Rubber Stamps
    • Mystical & Magical Rubber Stamps
  • Atomic Lizard Earrings
  • Ornaments
  • Coffee Mugs
  • Cryptid Collection
  • Sale items!
Log in

Country/region

  • USD $ | Australia
  • USD $ | Austria
  • USD $ | Belgium
  • USD $ | Canada
  • USD $ | Cook Islands
  • USD $ | Czechia
  • USD $ | Denmark
  • USD $ | Fiji
  • USD $ | Finland
  • USD $ | France
  • USD $ | French Polynesia
  • USD $ | Germany
  • USD $ | Hong Kong SAR
  • USD $ | Ireland
  • USD $ | Israel
  • USD $ | Italy
  • USD $ | Japan
  • USD $ | Kiribati
  • USD $ | Kuwait
  • USD $ | Malaysia
  • USD $ | Mexico
  • USD $ | Nauru
  • USD $ | Netherlands
  • USD $ | New Caledonia
  • USD $ | New Zealand
  • USD $ | Norfolk Island
  • USD $ | Norway
  • USD $ | Papua New Guinea
  • USD $ | Philippines
  • USD $ | Pitcairn Islands
  • USD $ | Poland
  • USD $ | Portugal
  • USD $ | Samoa
  • USD $ | Singapore
  • USD $ | Solomon Islands
  • USD $ | South Korea
  • USD $ | Spain
  • USD $ | Sweden
  • USD $ | Switzerland
  • USD $ | Taiwan
  • USD $ | Thailand
  • USD $ | Timor-Leste
  • USD $ | Tokelau
  • USD $ | Ukraine
  • USD $ | United Arab Emirates
  • USD $ | United Kingdom
  • USD $ | United States
  • USD $ | Vanuatu
  • USD $ | Vatican City
  • USD $ | Vietnam
    Butter Side Down Stamps and Atomic Lizard Logo
    • Home
    • Catalog
    • Contact
    • About Us
    • Rubber Stamps
      • Rubber Stamp Information
      • All Rubber Stamps
      • Ancient World
        • Ancient World Rubber Stamps
        • Egyptian Rubber Stamps
        • Megaliths & Geoglyphs Rubber Stamps
      • Insects & Butterfly Rubber Stamps
        • Butterflies & Moths
        • Insects and Creepy Crawlies
      • Fantasy & Labyrinth Rubber Stamps
      • Fish and Marine Life Rubber Stamps
      • Fossil & Mineral Rubber Stamps
        • Fossil Rubber Stamps
        • Shark Tooth Rubber Stamps
        • Trilobite Rubber Stamps
        • Mineral Treasure Rubber Stamps
      • History Rubber Stamps
        • Medieval Rubber Stamps
        • Japan and Asia Rubber Stamps
        • Historical Rubber Stamps
      • Bigfoot, Monsters & Halloween
        • Halloween Rubber Stamps
        • Bigfoot & Cryptids
        • Monster Rubber Stamps
      • Odds and Ends
        • Animal Rubber Stamps
        • Odds & Ends Rubber Stamps
      • Teddy Bear Rubber Stamps
      • Mystical & Magical Rubber Stamps
    • Atomic Lizard Earrings
    • Ornaments
    • Coffee Mugs
    • Cryptid Collection
    • Sale items!

    Country/region

    • USD $ | Australia
    • USD $ | Austria
    • USD $ | Belgium
    • USD $ | Canada
    • USD $ | Cook Islands
    • USD $ | Czechia
    • USD $ | Denmark
    • USD $ | Fiji
    • USD $ | Finland
    • USD $ | France
    • USD $ | French Polynesia
    • USD $ | Germany
    • USD $ | Hong Kong SAR
    • USD $ | Ireland
    • USD $ | Israel
    • USD $ | Italy
    • USD $ | Japan
    • USD $ | Kiribati
    • USD $ | Kuwait
    • USD $ | Malaysia
    • USD $ | Mexico
    • USD $ | Nauru
    • USD $ | Netherlands
    • USD $ | New Caledonia
    • USD $ | New Zealand
    • USD $ | Norfolk Island
    • USD $ | Norway
    • USD $ | Papua New Guinea
    • USD $ | Philippines
    • USD $ | Pitcairn Islands
    • USD $ | Poland
    • USD $ | Portugal
    • USD $ | Samoa
    • USD $ | Singapore
    • USD $ | Solomon Islands
    • USD $ | South Korea
    • USD $ | Spain
    • USD $ | Sweden
    • USD $ | Switzerland
    • USD $ | Taiwan
    • USD $ | Thailand
    • USD $ | Timor-Leste
    • USD $ | Tokelau
    • USD $ | Ukraine
    • USD $ | United Arab Emirates
    • USD $ | United Kingdom
    • USD $ | United States
    • USD $ | Vanuatu
    • USD $ | Vatican City
    • USD $ | Vietnam
    Log in Cart

    Item added to your cart

    View cart
    Remove all

    48 products

    Filter and sort Filter

    Filter and sort

    Filter

    48 products

    Remove all
    Remove all

    48 products

    • FeeGee Mermaid Rubber Stamp

      FeeGee Mermaid Rubber Stamp

      Sale

      FeeGee Mermaid Rubber Stamp

      Regular price From $2.50 USD
      Regular price $5.00 USD Sale price From $2.50 USD
      Unit price /  per 
      Sale
    • Flying Mothman

      Flying Mothman Cryptid Monster Rubber Stamp

      Sale

      Flying Mothman Cryptid Monster Rubber Stamp

      Regular price From $3.50 USD
      Regular price $5.00 USD Sale price From $3.50 USD
      Unit price /  per 
      Sale
    • Giant Octopus Rubber Stamp

      Giant Octopus Rubber Stamp

      Giant Octopus Rubber Stamp

      Regular price From $5.50 USD
      Regular price $5.00 USD Sale price From $5.50 USD
      Unit price /  per 
    • Gray Alien Rubber Stamp

      Gray Alien Rubber Stamp

      Gray Alien Rubber Stamp

      Regular price From $5.00 USD
      Regular price $5.00 USD Sale price From $5.00 USD
      Unit price /  per 
    • Wyoming Jackalope cryptid

      Jackalope Jackrabbit Rubber Stamp

      Sold out

      Jackalope Jackrabbit Rubber Stamp

      Regular price From $5.00 USD
      Regular price $5.00 USD Sale price From $5.00 USD
      Unit price /  per 
      Sold out
    • Jersey Devil ceramic ornament

      Jersey Devil Ceramic Ornament

      Sold out

      Jersey Devil Ceramic Ornament

      Regular price $11.95 USD
      Regular price $11.95 USD Sale price $11.95 USD
      Unit price /  per 
      Sold out
    • 13th child of old Mother Leeds

      Jersey Devil Rubber Stamp 13th Child

      Jersey Devil Rubber Stamp 13th Child

      Regular price From $5.50 USD
      Regular price $5.50 USD Sale price From $5.50 USD
      Unit price /  per 
    • Jersey Devil Earrings

      Jersey Devil Spider Web Agate Dangle Earrings

      Jersey Devil Spider Web Agate Dangle Earrings

      Regular price $9.95 USD
      Regular price $9.95 USD Sale price $9.95 USD
      Unit price /  per 
    • Rampaging gigantic squid.

      Killer Squid Rubber Stamp

      Killer Squid Rubber Stamp

      Regular price From $6.50 USD
      Regular price $5.50 USD Sale price From $6.50 USD
      Unit price /  per 
    • Leviathan itself rises from the ocean depths.

      Leviathan Sea Monster Rubber Stamp

      Sale

      Leviathan Sea Monster Rubber Stamp

      Regular price From $3.50 USD
      Regular price $5.00 USD Sale price From $3.50 USD
      Unit price /  per 
      Sale
    • Loch Ness Monster by Urquhart Castle

      Loch Ness Monster Rubber Stamp

      Loch Ness Monster Rubber Stamp

      Regular price From $5.00 USD
      Regular price $5.00 USD Sale price From $5.00 USD
      Unit price /  per 
    • Misunderstood Sasquatch Hunters Coffee Mug

      Misunderstood Sasquatch Hunters Coffee Mug

      Misunderstood Sasquatch Hunters Coffee Mug

      Regular price $17.95 USD
      Regular price $14.95 USD Sale price $17.95 USD
      Unit price /  per 
    • Mothman Ceramic Ornament

      Mothman Ceramic Ornament

      Sold out

      Mothman Ceramic Ornament

      Regular price $11.95 USD
      Regular price $11.95 USD Sale price $11.95 USD
      Unit price /  per 
      Sold out
    • Mothman cryptid earrings

      Mothman Earrings

      Sale

      Mothman Earrings

      Regular price $9.95 USD
      Regular price $11.95 USD Sale price $9.95 USD
      Unit price /  per 
      Sale
    • Mothman Moon Rubber Stamp

      Mothman Moon Rubber Stamp

      Mothman Moon Rubber Stamp

      Regular price From $5.00 USD
      Regular price $5.00 USD Sale price From $5.00 USD
      Unit price /  per 
    • New Jersey Cryptid Hunters Coffee Mug

      New Jersey Cryptid Hunters Coffee Mug

      New Jersey Cryptid Hunters Coffee Mug

      Regular price $17.95 USD
      Regular price $14.95 USD Sale price $17.95 USD
      Unit price /  per 
    • 1
    • 2
    • 3

    Subscribe for information on new products and special deals!

    Country/region

    • USD $ | Australia
    • USD $ | Austria
    • USD $ | Belgium
    • USD $ | Canada
    • USD $ | Cook Islands
    • USD $ | Czechia
    • USD $ | Denmark
    • USD $ | Fiji
    • USD $ | Finland
    • USD $ | France
    • USD $ | French Polynesia
    • USD $ | Germany
    • USD $ | Hong Kong SAR
    • USD $ | Ireland
    • USD $ | Israel
    • USD $ | Italy
    • USD $ | Japan
    • USD $ | Kiribati
    • USD $ | Kuwait
    • USD $ | Malaysia
    • USD $ | Mexico
    • USD $ | Nauru
    • USD $ | Netherlands
    • USD $ | New Caledonia
    • USD $ | New Zealand
    • USD $ | Norfolk Island
    • USD $ | Norway
    • USD $ | Papua New Guinea
    • USD $ | Philippines
    • USD $ | Pitcairn Islands
    • USD $ | Poland
    • USD $ | Portugal
    • USD $ | Samoa
    • USD $ | Singapore
    • USD $ | Solomon Islands
    • USD $ | South Korea
    • USD $ | Spain
    • USD $ | Sweden
    • USD $ | Switzerland
    • USD $ | Taiwan
    • USD $ | Thailand
    • USD $ | Timor-Leste
    • USD $ | Tokelau
    • USD $ | Ukraine
    • USD $ | United Arab Emirates
    • USD $ | United Kingdom
    • USD $ | United States
    • USD $ | Vanuatu
    • USD $ | Vatican City
    • USD $ | Vietnam
    Payment methods
    • American Express
    • Apple Pay
    • Diners Club
    • Discover
    • Google Pay
    • Mastercard
    • PayPal
    • Shop Pay
    • Venmo
    • Visa
    © 2026, Butter Side Down Powered by Shopify
    • Refund policy
    • Privacy policy
    • Terms of service
    • Shipping policy
    • Contact information
    • Choosing a selection results in a full page refresh.
    • Opens in a new window.